Skip to main content

EMV Liability Shift

TL;DR
  • Chip liability isn't one rule. Each network's code has its own tests on the card, terminal, region, transaction data and exclusions. They allocate a loss between the issuer and your acquirer (the bank behind your processor). What reaches you depends on your acceptance agreement
  • Counterfeit and lost, stolen or never-received claims are separate, with separate tests. Whether a PIN was used doesn't settle the second one alone
  • Contactless and mobile wallets have their own conditions. Don't assume they match a chip dip
  • US dates: ordinary point of sale from October 2015. ATM dates differ, 21 October 2016 on Mastercard and 1 October 2017 on Visa. Fuel and other regions have their own. On older hardware, check your terminal's certification status

A chip read failed, or an in-person sale came back as a counterfeit-fraud dispute? First check whether the chip was actually read, on a certified terminal with chip turned on, and whether the chip data reached the authorization and clearing records. EMV rules can move counterfeit fraud liability from the issuer to your acquirer when a chip card wasn't processed as a chip. That's the liability shift. Every condition below matters.

How Liability Shift Works​

The Basic Idea​

On eligible counterfeit fraud, responsibility can follow whoever didn't support the chip. That's a starting point, not the test. The network's card, terminal, region, required authorization and clearing data, and exclusions all apply (Visa rules, 24 October 2026, sections 4.1.17.45 and 11.8.2, pp. 254-255 and 692-696; Mastercard's guide, 13 May 2025, 4870, pp. 495-512).

TerminalCardWhere a counterfeit claim starts (issuer = the customer's bank)
Chip processed, required data sentChipWith the issuer
Chip terminal, chip data missingChipIt can land on your acquirer, then you. Check the code
No chip terminalChipIt can land on your acquirer, then you. Check the code
AnyNo chip (mag-stripe)This chip code doesn't apply. Other fraud rules can

What your acquirer charges you after that depends on your acceptance agreement.

The US Dates​

These are scheme and region milestones, not a guarantee that a later sale qualifies.

NetworkUS ordinary point of saleUS ATM
VisaOctober 20151 October 2017
Mastercard1 October 201521 October 2016 (guide, pp. 695-698)

Automated fuel dispensers and other regions have separate dates.

Chip authentication makes a card harder to copy (EMVCo). That's the reason for the shift, not a ranking of fraud by channel.


What "Chip Terminal" Really Means​

Having a terminal with a chip slot isn't enough. For the protection to hold:

Requirements​

RequirementWhy It Matters
EMV-capable terminalHardware must support chip
EMV enabledChip must be activated, not disabled
EMV certificationTerminal must be certified and deployed through your acquirer or processor
Chip processed on the transactionDip or tap, with the required data in authorization and clearing. Contactless has its own conditions

Common Mistakes​

MistakeResult
Chip terminal but EMV not enabledYou can lose a counterfeit claim
Swiping a chip card outside proper fallbackYou can lose a counterfeit claim
Fallback to swipe after a real chip failureProper technical fallback can be excluded. See fallback
Keying a card when the chip could workYou can lose a counterfeit claim. Qualifying keyed fallback has its own requirements

Transaction Types and Liability​

Chip Dip (Contact EMV)​

  • Card inserted into chip slot
  • The chip creates a one-time code for each payment
  • Counterfeit responsibility can stay with the issuer when the required data is sent and the code's tests are met

Contactless (Tap)​

  • Card or device tapped on terminal
  • Uses EMV technology
  • Check the network's contactless and verification conditions. They aren't always the same as a chip dip
  • Includes Apple Pay, Google Pay (tokenized)

Swipe (Mag-Stripe)​

  • Magnetic stripe read
  • On a chip card, a counterfeit claim can stand, unless it's proper technical fallback
  • Acceptable for non-chip cards

Keyed (Manual Entry)​

  • Numbers typed manually
  • No chip or swipe
  • No chip read to rely on. Qualifying keyed fallback can be excluded from Mastercard 4870, under its requirements
  • Measure your own keyed fraud and losses against other entry methods

Fallback Transactions​

When chip fails and you fall back to swipe:

What Can Cause Fallback​

  • A dirty or damaged chip
  • A terminal chip reader problem
  • A card chip fault
  • A fraud attempt, such as a manipulated card

Measure fallback and losses by entry method on your own transactions. Don't assume which of these you've got.

What Makes Fallback Proper​

It isn't a count of how many times it happened. The network looks at whether there was a real chip-processing failure, the required entry, terminal and card data, and the authorization and clearing coding and approval conditions. Proper fallback can be excluded from a counterfeit claim, including qualifying keyed fallback under Mastercard's requirements. A recorded fault alone isn't the whole test (Mastercard's guide, pp. 496 and 509, and the 4870 remedies; Visa rules, section 4.1.17.47, p. 255, and Table 11-11, p. 694).

A terminal that keeps falling back is a problem to investigate, whatever happens on one sale.

Fallback Best Practices​

  1. Always attempt chip first
  2. Re-insert chip if first attempt fails
  3. Clean the chip reader as the device maker instructs
  4. Request different card if repeated failure
  5. Document fallback reasons, and check your provider codes the fallback correctly

Reason Codes for Liability Shift Disputes​

Visa​

CodeNameWhen Used
10.1EMV Liability Shift (Counterfeit)An eligible counterfeit chip-card transaction whose full chip data didn't reach online authorization or offline clearing, under the regional terminal and data tests. Proper fallback is excluded
10.2EMV Liability Shift (Non-Counterfeit)A lost, stolen or never-received chip-and-PIN card, used where the terminal couldn't handle chip and PIN properly. Contactless and fallback sales are excluded, and so are US domestic sales

Mastercard​

CodeNameWhen Used
4870Chip Liability Shift: CounterfeitA counterfeit on a validly issued chip card, at a terminal that couldn't read chips or with the required chip data missing. Proper technical fallback is excluded. Europe's non-ATM Maestro use has its own route
4871Chip Liability Shift: Lost/StolenA lost, stolen or never-received chip card or qualifying device, under its card, terminal and verification tests and participating geography. Proper contactless and device verification cases are excluded

Amex​

CodeNameWhen Used
F30EMV CounterfeitA counterfeit chip card accepted in a qualifying lower-technology case, not every counterfeit
F31EMV Lost/Stolen/NRIA lost, stolen or never-received chip-and-PIN card, used with lower technology or without adequate PIN support, with issuer, merchant and acquirer all in designated countries after their effective dates. Properly identified fallback, contactless and digital-wallet sales are excluded

Conditions and responses are in Amex's rules, effective 24 October 2026, Tables 9-30 and 9-31, pp. 126-129.

Discover​

Use the code on your notice. Providers can show newer four-digit Discover codes from 17 April 2026 (Braintree's evidence guide). Older notices can use UA codes: one provider's list labels UA05 Chip Counterfeit Transaction and UA06 Chip and PIN Transaction (Moneris's guide, pp. 172-176). Those are a provider's labels, not Discover's current list.


Fighting EMV Liability Chargebacks​

What Can Support a Response​

Get the actual card, terminal, entry-mode, authorization and clearing records for the remedy you're claiming. A receipt, certificate or log supports that. It isn't an automatic win (Mastercard's guide, 4870 pp. 504-509, 4871 pp. 533-540; Visa rules, sections 11.8.2 and 11.8.3).

ScenarioWhat to gather
Chip was actually usedChip data in the authorization and clearing records, with the receipt as support
Terminal is certifiedCertification documents, as support. They don't show how this sale ran
Card wasn't chip-enabledThe card's record. A BIN lookup alone doesn't prove this card's chip or service code
Technical malfunction documentedTerminal logs, plus the fallback coding in authorization and first presentment

When a Response Is Harder​

ScenarioWhy
Swiped a chip card, outside proper fallbackThe chip was available and wasn't used
Keyed a card without a qualifying fallbackNo chip data to show
EMV not enabledA configuration issue on your side
Frequent fallbackThe count doesn't decide a case, but it can point to a terminal problem

Evidence to Collect​

EvidencePurpose
Transaction receiptSupports the entry method (chip/swipe/keyed)
Terminal certification docsSupports EMV capability
Terminal batch reportShows transaction details
Chip data (ARQC/TC)Shows the chip was read, if it's in the required messages. Ask your processor for the chip data on the transaction

Contactless and Mobile Wallet Liability​

Mobile Wallets (Apple Pay, Google Pay)​

FactorWhat to check
TokenizedToken represents card, not actual number. That isn't a blanket network protection
Device authenticationA biometric or PIN on the device, with exceptions. Apple's Express Mode can use an eligible payment or transit card without authenticating each payment
LiabilityCheck the actual verification result, region and fraud condition

Contactless Cards​

FactorWhat to check
EMV contactlessUses chip technology wirelessly
Liability shiftDepends on the code. Visa 10.2 excludes contactless in its stated tests, and Mastercard has its own verification and contactless exclusions (Visa rules, Table 11-17, pp. 698-699; Mastercard's guide, pp. 526-527)

Special Cases​

Card-Present but Keyed​

Sometimes you have the card but can't dip/swipe:

  • Damaged chip and mag-stripe
  • Reader malfunction

Liability: Don't assume. In-person manual entry needs its actual processing classification and any qualifying technical-fallback conditions. Otherwise a keyed sale has no chip read to rely on. A phone order is card-not-present, even if the customer has the card in hand.

Best practice: If chip and swipe both fail, request different payment method or decline transaction.

Hotel and Rental Pre-Authorization​

ScenarioWhat applies
Initial auth (check-in)Eligibility is checked on that transaction
Incremental authHas its own eligibility. May not be card-present
Final capture or a delayed chargeHas its own linked-transaction and processing conditions

Hotels and rentals have special rules allowing delayed and incremental charges. An earlier chip read doesn't cover them automatically. Visa's delayed-charge exclusion has its own conditions, and Mastercard's later-charge remedies need their own data (Visa rules, Table 11-17, p. 699; Mastercard's guide, pp. 526-540).

Recurring Transactions​

ScenarioWhat applies
Initial chip transactionEligibility is checked on that transaction
Subsequent recurringMIT (merchant-initiated) rules apply
Stored credentialHas its own conditions, not just the original capture method

Don't assume the first chip read protects later charges on the saved card. Charges you start later, without the customer there, follow their own rules. Ask your processor: "Which later charges on a saved card are protected, against which fraud claims, under my account terms?"


Terminal Compliance​

EMV Certification Process​

StepDescription
1. L1Mechanical and electrical interface testing
2. L2The terminal's EMV kernel and application logic
3. L3End-to-end integration with payment-system requirements (EMVCo)
4. DeploymentYour processor or acquirer's process for activating it in production

Maintaining Compliance​

ActionFrequency
Firmware updatesAs released
Certification renewalsPer network requirements
Security patchesImmediately
Reader cleaningAs the device maker instructs

Terminal Inspection Checklist​

  • Chip slot clean and unobstructed
  • No overlays on chip slot or PIN pad
  • Tamper-evident seals intact
  • Firmware current
  • EMV enabled (not bypassed)

Regional and Network Variations​

Visa​

  • US ordinary point of sale: October 2015. US ATM: 1 October 2017
  • Gas stations extended to April 2021
  • Regional eligibility and exclusions are in section 11.8.2, pp. 692-696

Mastercard​

American Express​

  • Liability shift effective October 2015
  • SafeKey is an online authentication product, separate from chip at a terminal
  • Conditions and responses are in its rules, Tables 9-30 and 9-31, pp. 126-127

Discover​

  • ProtectBuy for authentication
  • Use the code on your notice, and ask your acquirer for the current chip rules

Future: Tap-to-Phone​

Emerging technology allows phones to act as terminals:

FactorStatus
TechnologyPhone accepts contactless payments
CertificationNetwork programs exist (Visa Tap to Phone, etc.)
Liability shiftBeing on a phone doesn't decide it. It turns on the solution's certification, the transaction data and the network's condition
SecuritySoftware-based security model

Scale Callout​

VolumeFocus
Under $50k/mo CPCheck your terminals are EMV-enabled. Don't overthink.
$50k-$250k/mo CPMonitor fallback rates. Clean readers regularly.
$250k-$1M/mo CPTrack liability shift chargebacks. Investigate patterns.
Over $1M/mo CPDedicated terminal management. Regular certification audits.

Where This Breaks​

  1. Assuming chip = protected. Terminal certified, EMV enabled, chip actually processed, required data sent, and the code's tests met. Check them all.

  2. Ignoring fallback rates. High fallback rates signal terminal issues and potential liability gaps. Monitor and fix.

  3. Keyed transactions for "convenience." A keyed sale has no chip read to rely on. Cut them back.


Next Steps​

Understanding liability shift?

  1. Card-Present Fraud: CP fraud types and prevention
  2. EMV & Contactless: Operational guide for chip payments
  3. Card-Present Terminal Decisions: Terminal selection

Fighting EMV chargebacks?

  1. Chargeback Lifecycle: Understand dispute timelines
  2. Compelling Evidence: Build your defense
  3. Representment: Response strategies

Optimizing terminal operations?

  1. Terminal Operations: Managing terminal fleet
  2. Terminal Security: Physical security controls
  3. Digital Wallets: Contactless wallet benefits

Something wrong on this page? Email matt at paymentsandrisk.com and say what needs fixing.