Skip to main content

Zero Point Nine Panic

Prerequisites

Before crisis response, understand:

Your chargeback ratio hit 0.9%. You're 0.1% from Visa's threshold and your processor is sending warning emails. This is not the time for a comprehensive fraud strategy. This is triage.

The cash flow spiral starts now: processor holds more reserves, payouts slow, you can't fund inventory or ads, sales drop, ratio gets worse. Break the cycle today.

Crisis Response Timeline​

What Matters​

  1. Stop the bleeding first. New chargebacks hurt more than old ones right now.
  2. Deflection tools work in 24-48 hours. Alerts and RDR can start catching disputes immediately.
  3. Refund generously this week. A refund costs less than a chargeback.
  4. Your ratio is a 30-day rolling window. Today's actions affect next month's math.
  5. MATCH listing is a 5-year death sentence. Avoid it at almost any cost.

Hour 1: Immediate Actions​

Do these now. Not after lunch. Now.

Stop Risky Transactions​

  • Pause high-risk product sales if you have clear problem SKUs
  • Increase fraud screening aggressiveness temporarily (accept higher false positives)
  • Require 3DS on all transactions if you weren't already
  • Block high-risk countries you don't need

Contact Your Processor​

Call, don't email.

  • Ask: "What's my current ratio and what's the threshold?"
  • Ask: "Am I in a monitoring program or warning period?"
  • Ask: "What happens if I breach next month?"
  • Tell them: "I'm implementing remediation today. What do you need from me?"

Processors want you to succeed. They make money when you process. But they need to see action.

Enable Deflection Tools​

If you don't have these, sign up today:

ToolWhat It DoesTime to Active
Verifi RDRAuto-refunds Visa disputes before they become chargebacks24-48 hours
Ethoca AlertsNotifies you of Mastercard disputes for manual refund24-48 hours
CDRNNotifies you of Visa disputes for manual refund24-48 hours

RDR is the fastest win. You set rules (e.g., "auto-refund all disputes under $100"), and matching disputes never become chargebacks.

Cost: $15-40 per alert/resolution. Cheap compared to a $50+ chargeback fee plus ratio damage.

Day 1: Stabilization​

Audit Recent Transactions​

Pull the last 7 days of orders. Flag:

  • High-ticket items to new customers
  • International orders (if you're domestic-focused)
  • Rush shipping requests
  • Mismatched billing/shipping
  • Velocity anomalies (same card, same device, same address)

Consider proactively refunding suspicious orders before they become chargebacks.

Customer Support Blitz​

Your support team is your front line.

Immediate changes:

  • Authorize support to issue refunds up to $X without approval
  • Reduce response time target to < 4 hours
  • Add a "billing question?" prominent link in all customer-facing areas
  • Script: "I can refund this right now. Would that help?"

Track: Every customer who contacts support about a charge they don't recognize. These are chargebacks waiting to happen.

Check Your Descriptor​

Pull your actual bank statement appearance. Does it:

  • Show your brand name clearly?
  • Include a phone number or URL?
  • Make sense to someone who forgot what they bought?

If your descriptor says "STRIPE* PYMT 800-555-1234" and your business is "Acme Dog Toys," you're generating "I don't recognize this" disputes.

Fix timeline: Descriptor changes take 1-3 days at most processors.

Week 1: Systematic Prevention​

Implement Refund-First Policy​

This week, refund first and investigate second.

SituationOld ResponseThis Week's Response
Customer says "I don't recognize this"Investigate, then decideRefund immediately
Customer says "I want to cancel"Explain cancellation policyRefund immediately
Customer says "It's not what I expected"Offer exchangeRefund immediately

Yes, you'll refund some bad-faith requests. The cost of a refund (2-3% of transaction) is lower than the cost of a chargeback ($50 fee + ratio damage + operational cost).

Proactive Outreach​

Contact customers from the last 30 days:

  • High-ticket purchases: "Hi, just checking that your order arrived and everything looks good."
  • Subscription renewals: "Your renewal is coming up on [date]. Want to continue?"
  • Anyone who contacted support: "Following up to make sure your issue was resolved."

This catches problems before they become disputes.

Review Cancellation Flow​

If customers can't find how to cancel, they dispute instead.

  • Is cancellation available in account settings?
  • Does it work on mobile?
  • Is there a confirmation email?
  • Can support cancel with one click?

Subscription Hygiene​

If you have recurring billing:

  • Send renewal reminders 7 days before charge
  • Make cancellation brain-dead simple
  • Confirm cancellations with email + timestamp
  • Stop charging immediately on cancellation (not "end of billing period")

Understanding Your Distance to Threshold​

Visa VAMP (effective April 2025)​

RatioStatus
< 0.9%Safe (for now)
0.9% - 1.5%Danger zone
> 1.5%Excessive. Fines start.

VAMP combines fraud reports (TC40) and disputes. Even if you refund via alerts, fraud-claimed TC40s still count.

Mastercard ECM​

ChargebacksRatioStatus
< 100 AND< 1.5%Safe
100-299 AND1.5-2.99%ECM. Fines start month 2.
300+ AND3%+HECM. Accelerated fines.

Mastercard requires BOTH count AND ratio to trigger. 150 chargebacks at 1.4% ratio = still safe.

The Math That Matters​

Your ratio = Chargebacks this month / Sales transactions last month

To improve your ratio, you can:

  1. Reduce chargebacks (fewer numerator)
  2. Increase sales (higher denominator)
  3. Wait for old chargebacks to roll off (time)

Short-term, focus on #1. Long-term, healthy growth helps #2.

MATCH/TMF: The Nuclear Option​

If your processor terminates you for excessive chargebacks, you go on the MATCH list.

What MATCH Means​

  • Listed for 5 years
  • Almost no legitimate processor will onboard you
  • High-risk specialists may, at 5-10% rates with 20%+ reserves
  • You effectively can't accept cards

What Triggers MATCH for Chargebacks​

  • Reason Code 04: Excessive chargebacks
  • Reason Code 05: Excessive fraud

Your processor decides when to list you. Usually after:

  • Breach of threshold for 3+ months
  • Failed remediation plan
  • Refusal to implement required changes

Avoiding MATCH​

  • Respond to processor warnings within 24 hours
  • Submit remediation plans when requested
  • Show month-over-month improvement
  • Communicate constantly with your processor
  • If breach is inevitable, negotiate a voluntary exit (no MATCH listing) before termination

When to Hire Help​

When a Chargeback Specialist Is Worth It​

  • Ratio above 1.5% with no internal capacity
  • Facing network program enrollment
  • Complex representment needs (high-ticket, international)
  • You need someone to manage alerts and representment full-time

What to Ask Before Hiring​

  1. "What's your win rate by reason code?" Good specialists track this.
  2. "How do you charge?" Per-dispute, retainer, or % of recovered funds.
  3. "Do you handle alerts, representment, or both?"
  4. "What's your typical client ratio improvement timeline?"

Caution​

Avoid expensive retainers without measurable targets. "We'll manage your chargebacks for $3k/mo" means nothing without:

  • Target ratio reduction
  • Expected timeline
  • Performance guarantees or reduced fees if targets missed

Test to Run​

7-day crisis stabilization:

Day 1:

  • Enable RDR and/or Ethoca alerts
  • Brief support team on refund-first policy
  • Check descriptor for clarity

Days 2-3:

  • Proactive outreach to recent high-ticket customers
  • Review and fix cancellation flow
  • Increase fraud rule aggressiveness

Days 4-7:

  • Monitor alert volume and resolution rate
  • Track support contacts about billing
  • Calculate projected next-month ratio

Success criteria: Visible reduction in dispute inflow within 7 days. Ratio stabilization within 30 days.

Scale Callout​

VolumeFocus
Under $100k/moRDR + refund generously. You don't have the volume to absorb many chargebacks.
$100k-$1M/moFull alert stack (RDR + Ethoca + CDRN). Dedicated support person for billing issues.
Over $1M/moDedicated chargeback analyst. Real-time ratio monitoring. Consider representment vendor.

Where This Breaks​

  1. True fraud attack. If you're being hit by organized fraud, refunding doesn't help. You need to stop the fraud at the door. See Survive a Fraud Attack.

  2. Product/service problems. If customers are disputing because your product is bad, no amount of alerts will fix it. Fix the product or exit the business.

  3. Subscription confusion. If customers don't know they're being charged recurring, you have a disclosure problem. Fix the signup flow.

Analyst Layer: Metrics to Track​

MetricWhat It Tells YouTarget
Daily dispute inflowAre things getting worse?Trending down
Alert-to-refund rateAre you catching disputes?> 80% of alerts refunded
Support contacts about billingLeading indicator of disputesTrending down
Ratio projectionWhere will you be next month?Below threshold
Dispute reason code distributionWhat type of disputes?Identifies root cause

Daily Ratio Tracking​

During crisis, track daily:

Today's ratio estimate = (Chargebacks in rolling 30 days) / (Sales in prior 30 days)

Plot it. Watch the trend. Celebrate when it turns.

Next Steps​

In a crisis right now?

  1. Follow the Reduce Chargebacks Fast playbook → Immediate triage steps
  2. Set up dispute alerts today → Stop chargebacks before they hit
  3. Calculate your exact ratio → Know how close you are to thresholds

Stabilizing after a spike?

  1. Analyze your dispute reasons → What's driving the chargebacks?
  2. Fix root causes → Descriptors, refund process, customer communication
  3. Build monitoring → Daily ratio tracking to catch problems early

Preventing the next crisis?

  1. Understand VAMP/ECM thresholds → Know the program rules
  2. Set internal thresholds lower than network limits → Early warning system
  3. Review chargeback prevention → Systematic prevention