Skip to main content

Economics of Fraud

TL;DR
  • Total fraud cost = Direct loss + chargeback fees + review labor + tool costs + program fees
  • Blocked good orders cost margin and future sales. Measure that cost alongside actual fraud losses
  • Goal: minimize net fraud cost (fraud loss + false positive loss + prevention cost), not just fraud rate
  • Compare strategies on your own costs, not just how much fraud they block
  • See Risk Appetite for tolerance framework

Fraud costs more than the payment you lose. Add fees, review time and tools, then compare that with the margin lost on good orders you block. For illustration: 700 legitimate orders x $100 x 40% margin = $28,000 in lost margin. This page shows you how to compare the two.

Assumed costs: $50 + $25 + $20 + $5 = $100 out of pocket. The $100 sale was reversed, so there's no sale revenue left to offset them. Don't add the reversed revenue again as another cash expense.

Quick SMB Math​

Before reading the detailed breakdown below, ask this first: is my fraud loss big enough to justify spending money on it?

Simple formula: Monthly fraud loss = Monthly sales dollars x dollar fraud rate

For illustration, $100,000 monthly sales x 0.3% dollar fraud rate = $300/month in fraudulent sales. If you're using a fraud rate by count instead, use monthly order count x count fraud rate x average fraudulent order value. Add fees and unrecovered fulfillment costs separately. Before buying a $500/month fraud tool, compare its cost with the losses it could actually prevent.

These are suggested starting points, not spending rules. Tune them to your losses, margin and processor limits.

Monthly Fraud LossWhat to Do
Under $500/monthStart with free fixes: your billing descriptor (how) and your processor's controls
$500-$2,000/monthTune existing rules and check whether chargeback alerts cover the disputes you receive
$2,000-$5,000/monthQuote a paid tool or guarantee, then test whether it pays
Over $5,000/monthEvaluate a pilot. Compare measured loss savings with tool fees and lost good orders
Check Program Entry Tests, Not Just Volume

Volume alone doesn't tell you whether a program applies. Check your processor's written limit and the network programs' ratio, count and regional conditions. Don't assume you're exempt below $1M/month.

The Full Cost of Fraud​

Fraud cost extends far beyond the direct dollar loss:

Total Fraud Cost = Direct Loss + Operational Cost + Chargeback Fees + Recovery Cost

Direct Loss Components​

ComponentDescriptionWhat to Use
Transaction AmountRevenue reversed on the fraudulent saleActual reversal; track separately from cash costs
Product/Service CostYour COGS on the fraudUnrecovered cost from the order record
ShippingFulfillment cost (if applicable)What you paid, less any recovery
Payment FeesProcessing fees you don't get backYour statement and refund terms

Indirect Costs​

ComponentDescriptionWhat to Use
Chargeback FeePer-dispute processor feeYour agreement; verified provider table
Review LaborManual investigation timeMinutes per case x loaded hourly cost / 60
Tool/Vendor CostFraud prevention stackYour invoice, implementation and maintenance costs
Program FeesNetwork monitoring programsApplicable program terms, and what your acquirer (the bank behind your processor) passes through

The False Positive Problem​

Hidden Cost

Blocked good orders have a cost. Measure it alongside fraud losses.

Calculating False Positive Cost​

FP Cost = Blocked Good Transactions × Average Order Value × Gross Margin

Example:

  • 1,000 transactions blocked
  • 70% were actually legitimate (700 false positives)
  • $100 average order value
  • 40% gross margin
  • FP Cost = 700 × $100 × 40% = $28,000

The Trade-off​

Illustrative monthly losses, not measured benchmarks:

ApproachFraud LossFalse Positive LossTotal Loss
Very Aggressive$5,000$50,000$5,000 + $50,000 = $55,000
Balanced$15,000$15,000$15,000 + $15,000 = $30,000
Very Permissive$40,000$2,000$40,000 + $2,000 = $42,000

Optimizing the Trade-off​

Key Levers​

  1. Improve model precision: Better targeting reduces both fraud and FPs
  2. Segment your rules: Different risk tolerance by customer segment
  3. Use friction wisely: Ask for an extra identity check instead of declining the order
  4. Invest in review: Manual review for gray zone, not auto-decline

Measuring Success​

Track Net Fraud Cost:

Net Fraud Cost = Fraud Loss + False Positive Loss + Prevention Cost

Goal: Minimize net fraud cost, not just fraud rate.

Next Steps​

Calculating your fraud costs?

  1. Add up full costs: Include indirect costs
  2. Calculate false positive cost: Can be the bigger problem
  3. Find your trade-off sweet spot: Balance both sides

Optimizing the trade-off?

  1. Define risk appetite: Set clear targets
  2. Improve model precision: Better targeting
  3. Use step-up auth: Friction where needed

Measuring success?

  1. Track net fraud cost: Not just fraud rate
  2. Review fraud metrics: Full picture
  3. Compare to benchmarks: Industry standards

Something wrong on this page? Email matt at paymentsandrisk.com and say what needs fixing.