Skip to main content

Mastercard 4853 - Cardholder Dispute

TL;DR
  • Mastercard's code for specified cardholder-dispute conditions: non-receipt, quality complaints, credit not processed and cancelled recurring among them. Duplicates and processing errors belong to 4834, and unauthorized participation to 4837
  • Check the filing window for the specific claim, delivery facts and region
  • Your evidence depends entirely on which sub-claim the issuer filed. Read the notification before you build the packet
  • The May 2025 guide places non-delivery under 4853 and doesn't list 4855 as an active Dual Message code. Notice says 4855? Start here

Got this code?​

Your deadline: The date on your notice wins. Ask your processor if it isn't clear: the network's issuer filing window isn't your response deadline.

The claim: One of the specified cardholder-dispute conditions, including non-receipt and quality issues. It doesn't cover every billing or processing complaint.

Records that answer it:

  1. Which category the issuer filed: not received, not as described, or cancelled recurring?
  2. For not received: delivery proof
  3. For not as described: your product description as it stood at the sale
  4. For cancelled recurring: your cancellation records

Next: Decide whether it's worth fighting, then fill in the response outline for your claim and follow the Representment Workflow.

Records by what you sell​

The same claim needs different records depending on what you sold. Find the claim on your notice, then your column.

They say it never arrived​

What you sellShipped goodsDigital or onlineIn person or a service
Records that answer it
  • Carrier tracking showing delivery to the address on the order
  • Signed proof of delivery, or the signed pickup form for a collected order
  • The shipping label or receipt with the full address
  • Access or download logs after the payment, with IP addresses and timestamps
  • The customer's IP address, name and email at purchase
  • The signed contract, work order or completion record, with the service date
  • Customer messages from before the dispute
Where to find them
  • Shopify: Orders, open the order, then Add evidence on the chargeback banner. Shopify attaches a PDF of the order's fulfillment events itself
  • Stripe: Counter dispute on the dispute details page: shipping_carrier, shipping_tracking_number, shipping_date, shipping_documentation. Stripe expands the tracking number into the carrier's delivery detail
  • Square: Orders & payments > Disputes, in the dispute's information request form
  • Your own server or app logs: you supply this record
  • Stripe: Counter dispute on the dispute details page: access_activity_log, customer_purchase_ip
  • Shopify: Orders, open the order, then Add evidence on the chargeback banner, as the activity log Shopify asks for
  • Your booking or job records
  • Stripe: Counter dispute on the dispute details page: service_date, service_documentation, customer_communication
  • Square: the payment's receipt in Orders & payments > Transactions; attach the records in the dispute form

Sources: Stripe's evidence by product type VENDOR; Shopify's evidence by reason VENDOR; Shopify's chargeback response page VENDOR; Square's dispute walkthrough VENDOR; Square's transaction search VENDOR. Source links accessed 24 October 2026; follow the labels shown in your processor dashboard.

They say it wasn't as described​

What you sellShipped goodsDigital or onlineIn person or a service
Records that answer it
  • Your product description and photos as the customer saw them before buying
  • Your refund policy and how you showed it before purchase
  • Customer messages, and whether they returned the item
  • The description of the product or service as it was represented
  • Access logs showing the customer used it
  • Your refund policy and how you showed it
  • The service as you advertised it, and the agreed scope
  • Your refund policy and how you showed it
  • Customer messages about the complaint
Where to find them
  • Shopify: Orders, open the order, then Add evidence on the chargeback banner, with descriptions or pictures from your store, plus fulfillment and tracking
  • Stripe: Counter dispute on the dispute details page: product_description, refund_policy, refund_policy_disclosure, customer_communication
  • Square: Orders & payments > Disputes, in the dispute's information request form
  • Stripe: Counter dispute on the dispute details page: product_description, access_activity_log, refund_policy
  • Your own server or app logs for the access record
  • Shopify: Orders, open the order, then Add evidence on the chargeback banner
  • Stripe: Counter dispute on the dispute details page: product_description, refund_policy, customer_communication
  • Square: the payment in Orders & payments > Transactions; attach the records in the dispute form
  • Your agreement or booking records

Sources: Stripe's evidence by product type VENDOR; Shopify's evidence by reason VENDOR; Shopify's chargeback response page VENDOR; Square's dispute walkthrough VENDOR; Square's transaction search VENDOR. Source links accessed 24 October 2026; follow the labels shown in your processor dashboard.

They say they cancelled recurring payments​

What you sellShipped goodsDigital or onlineIn person or a service
Records that answer it
  • Your cancellation policy as the customer saw it, and when
  • Renewal notices you sent
  • Your cancellation log: no request, or one after this charge
  • Your cancellation policy and how you showed it before purchase
  • Activity logs showing use after the date they say they cancelled
  • Renewal notices you sent
  • Your cancellation policy and how you showed it
  • Service dates and records after the claimed cancellation
  • Renewal notices and the customer's replies
Where to find them
  • Shopify: Orders, open the order, then Add evidence on the chargeback banner, with the policy, your cancellation emails and when the customer saw the policy
  • Stripe: Counter dispute on the dispute details page: cancellation_policy, cancellation_policy_disclosure, cancellation_rebuttal, customer_communication
  • Square: Orders & payments > Disputes, in the dispute's information request form
  • Shopify: Orders, open the order, then Add evidence on the chargeback banner, with an activity log of access after the claimed cancellation
  • Stripe: Counter dispute on the dispute details page: cancellation_policy, cancellation_rebuttal, customer_communication
  • Your own server or app logs for the activity record
  • Stripe: Counter dispute on the dispute details page: cancellation_policy, service_date, service_documentation
  • Square: the payments in Orders & payments > Transactions; attach the records in the dispute form
  • Your booking or membership records

Sources: Stripe's evidence by product type VENDOR; Shopify's evidence by reason VENDOR; Shopify's chargeback response page VENDOR; Square's dispute walkthrough VENDOR; Square's transaction search VENDOR. Source links accessed 24 October 2026; follow the labels shown in your processor dashboard.

Dispute Categories Under 4853​

Goods or Services Not as Described​

What arrived differs materially from what was described.

Common scenarios:

  • Product quality doesn't match description
  • Wrong item shipped
  • Services not performed as agreed
  • Digital goods don't function as advertised

Goods or Services Not Received​

The customer didn't receive the merchandise or services purchased.

Common scenarios:

  • Physical goods never delivered
  • Digital goods not accessible
  • Services not performed
  • Partial delivery (missing items)

Credit Not Processed​

A refund the customer was due wasn't processed. That includes more than a promise you made: an undisclosed policy followed by refusing a return or cancellation, not responding, a reduced refund without proper disclosure, and qualifying tax refunds that weren't issued. A properly disclosed and accepted policy matters, as do the guide's specific travel and entertainment conditions.

Common scenarios:

  • Return accepted, no credit issued
  • Cancellation processed, no refund
  • Merchant promised refund, didn't process

Cancelled Recurring Transaction​

A qualifying charge after cancellation, or a recurring arrangement the customer says they didn't know about or agree to. A disclosed and accepted trial conversion isn't by itself an invalid recurring charge.

Common scenarios:

  • Subscription cancellation ignored
  • Trial period ended, charges began
  • Cancellation confirmation received but still billed

Digital Goods Examples​

Ordinary digital non-delivery and quality complaints use the applicable goods or services condition above. Mastercard also has a specific low-value digital-goods purchase-control condition: a ceiling of USD/EUR 25 or local equivalent, established stored credentials, an account in good standing with no associated fraud, and specified purchase-control failures. It isn't a general digital-dispute bucket.

Common scenarios:

  • Download link expired or invalid
  • Software key doesn't work
  • Streaming service not accessible
  • In-app purchase not delivered

Time Frames​

ClaimIssuer filing window (the bank's deadline, not yours)
Issuer filing: ordinary non-delivery120 calendar days from the date the sale settled (or its applicable network business date), or from the latest expected delivery or performance date where that applies. Mainland China domestic delayed delivery: 90 calendar days
Issuer filing: interrupted ongoing services120 calendar days from when the customer learned the service had stopped, and no later than 540 calendar days from first-presentment settlement (or the network business date). Mainland China domestic: 90 days from learning, capped at 540 from transaction settlement
Other 4853 claimsEach condition has its own clock. Don't carry the non-delivery window across

A chargeback filed after its window can be invalid. Ask your processor, which works with your acquirer (the bank behind your processor): "Which claim and Mastercard rule apply to this case, and what's my last date to send you evidence?" (Mastercard Chargeback Guide, 13 May 2025, Goods or Services Not Provided, pp. 149-152)

Cardholder Requirements​

What the customer has to do first depends on the condition:

  1. Merchant contact, return or repair attempts - Only where that condition requires them. Non-delivery has no universal prior-contact requirement
  2. No delivery date given - A 30-day wait applies before a non-delivery filing, unless item 3 applies
  3. Earlier action is possible - The issuer can act sooner if you won't provide the goods or services
  4. A promised date normally has to pass - For non-receipt claims, subject to that same won't-provide exception

Merchant Response Options​

For Not As Described​

Representment available when:

  • Goods/services matched description
  • Customer was provided accurate information
  • Goods or services were repaired or replaced
  • A ground that makes the chargeback itself invalid applies

Evidence required:

  • Product description/listing as shown to the customer
  • Records showing the goods or services were as agreed, or were repaired or replaced. Accepted terms or use on their own don't prove the description or quality was met
  • Where the claim needs it, further corroboration answering the customer's expert evidence
  • Communications about the product

For Not Received​

Representment available when:

  • Delivery confirmed to correct address
  • Customer signed for delivery
  • Tracking shows delivered
  • Digital goods were accessed

Evidence required:

  • The delivery or performance record that fits this sale: tracking, a photograph, pickup records, ticket use, locker-code use, access logs or service-performance documents
  • A signature or carrier tracking can help. Neither is mandatory in every case
  • Access logs for digital goods
  • Delivery carrier confirmation

For Credit Not Processed​

Representment available when:

  • A qualifying refund was processed before second presentment. Offset only the portion actually credited
  • The actual credit transaction is linked to this purchase. Saying it will appear on a future statement isn't evidence it was processed
  • No refund was due per terms

Evidence required:

  • Proof of credit with its date and reference, or the compelling evidence an alternate refund method requires
  • Credit transaction details
  • Terms showing refund not applicable

For Cancelled Recurring​

Representment available when:

  • A documented eligible ground answers this complaint. Saying you didn't receive a cancellation isn't a defense on its own
  • The charge belongs to a finite installment arrangement, not a recurring one, and fits that arrangement
  • The recurring disclosure and acceptance hold up, the guide's cancellation conditions are met, and any post-cancellation service you rely on was provided and used

Evidence required:

  • Cancellation policy
  • Disclosure and acceptance records for the recurring arrangement. A missing cancellation record doesn't prove continuing permission
  • Transaction occurred before cancellation
  • Where you rely on it, records showing post-cancellation service was provided and used

Second Presentment Requirements​

Second presentment is Mastercard's name for sending your evidence back to fight the chargeback. Your processor files it; you give it what's below.

Evidence and message requirements​

Mastercard doesn't require a set message wording for the as-described, delivery or ordinary recurring grounds. Send the specified evidence and let your acquirer use the condition's own reason code and message requirements. Refund responses are different: for a refund to a Mastercard account, the processor's message links the credit date and Acquirer Reference Data. Mainland China uses its specified comment and Network Reference Number path. Alternate refund methods need their compelling evidence (Chargeback Guide, pp. 136, 138-139, 154-156 and 263).

Documentation Standards​

  • Must be legible
  • Must be relevant to specific dispute
  • Must be submitted within time frame
  • At chargeback, second presentment and pre-arbitration, translate the relevant parts into English when issuer and acquirer don't share a language. At arbitration, documents must be in English, with the Brazil English or Portuguese exception

Second Presentment Time Frames​

These are acquirer clocks, not a guaranteed merchant response period. Each row counts from the date the chargeback settled (or its applicable network business date).

RegionWindow
Standard second presentment45 calendar days from the date the chargeback settled (or its applicable network business date)
Costa Rica domestic second presentment10 calendar days from the date the chargeback settled (or its applicable network business date)
Kazakhstan domestic second presentment30 calendar days from the date the chargeback settled (or its applicable network business date)
Mainland China domestic second presentment30 calendar days from the date the chargeback settled (or its applicable network business date)
Nigeria domestic second presentment2 business days from the date the chargeback settled (or its applicable network business date)
Tanzania domestic second presentment20 calendar days from the date the chargeback settled (or its applicable network business date)

Pre-Arbitration​

When Issuer Can File​

This is the issuer submitting a pre-arbitration case after second presentment. It isn't your or your acquirer's reply deadline. The chargeback has to be valid and second presentment must not have remedied it. Documentation conditions and ATM and Maestro escalation paths are separate.

  • Second presentment evidence insufficient
  • Customer provides additional information
  • Documentation doesn't address dispute

Time Frames​

RegionWindow
Issuer pre-arbitration filing: ordinary non-ATM and non-MaestroIssuer: 30 calendar days in the standard case, from the date the second presentment settled or its applicable network business date
Issuer pre-arbitration filing: Costa Rica domesticIssuer: 10 calendar days from the date the second presentment settled or its applicable network business date
Issuer pre-arbitration filing: Tanzania domesticIssuer: 10 calendar days from the date the second presentment settled or its applicable network business date

Which defenses hold up​

Dispute TypeWith EvidenceWithout Evidence
Not receivedDelivery records show receipt or digital accessCan't show receipt or access
Not as describedListing and records show the goods or services were as agreed, or repaired or replacedCan't show the goods or services matched the description
Credit not processedRefund records show the credit was issuedCan't show the credit was issued
Cancelled recurringDisclosure and acceptance records, the cancellation conditions, and any post-cancellation service provided and used support the chargeCan't show the charge was still authorized

Track your own win rate by reason code instead of relying on a general figure.

Common Mistakes​

  1. No delivery or performance record for this sale - Nothing ties delivery or the service to this customer
  2. Vague descriptions - Product listing doesn't match
  3. Slow refunds - Customer files a chargeback before the credit posts
  4. Poor cancellation process - Hard to cancel = chargebacks
  5. No communication records - Can't prove customer interaction

Retired 4855: Goods or Services Not Provided​

The 13 May 2025 Mastercard Chargeback Guide puts goods or services not provided under 4853. It doesn't list 4855. NETWORK Checked 22 October 2026.

Seeing 4855 on a notification? Older notices may still show it. Ask your processor for the actual case code, non-delivery claim and response date. Don't treat the label alone as proof the notice is stale. For a 4853 non-receipt response, gather delivery or service-performance evidence.

Fighting a non-receipt claim under 4853? Match what happened to the evidence below. The Not Received list covers the basics.

What happenedEvidence
Goods were deliveredDelivery tracking number, carrier confirmation, signature if applicable, photo proof of delivery, GPS or timestamp confirmation
Digital goods were accessedDownload logs, access and login records, usage data, IP address at access time, email delivery confirmation
Services were renderedService completion records, customer signature on completion, photos or documentation of the work, time logs with customer approval, communication confirming completion
Customer picked upIn-store pickup records, ID verification at pickup, signature on the pickup receipt, video footage if available
Refund already issuedRefund transaction record, ARN, settlement confirmation

Special cases

  • Delayed delivery. Tell the customer early, offer alternatives, set new expectations, consider a partial refund
  • Partial delivery. Document what was delivered, ship missing items as soon as you can, give partial credit if needed, keep communication open
  • Cancelled events or services. Process the refund promptly, send a clear cancellation notice, offer alternatives, document the cancellation
  • International shipping. Expect longer timelines, keep the customs documentation, use tracking that survives the border, and insure the shipment

For services and digital goods, prevention looks like the evidence: get a completion sign-off, document progress with before and after photos, define the scope up front, and track milestones. Deliver download links on payment, email the access details, log downloads and logins, and give the customer more than one way in.

Prevention Strategies​

For Non-Receipt Claims​

  1. Use tracking on all shipments - Carrier confirmation
  2. Require signature for high-value - Proof of receipt
  3. Send shipping notifications - Email with tracking
  4. Insure valuable shipments - Carrier liability
  5. Photograph packaging - Evidence of condition

For Quality Disputes​

  1. Accurate descriptions - No exaggeration
  2. Quality photos/videos - Show actual product
  3. Clear specifications - Size, color, materials
  4. Manage expectations - Realistic delivery times
  5. Quality control - Inspect before shipping

For Credit Not Processed​

  1. Process refunds promptly
  2. Send confirmation - Email with details
  3. Provide timeline - When credit will appear
  4. Keep records - Refund transaction IDs

For Recurring Cancellations​

  1. Easy cancellation process - Same channel as signup
  2. Confirmation emails - Document cancellation
  3. Honor requests immediately - Don't charge after
  4. Send reminders - Before renewal charges
  5. Clear terms - Cancellation policy visible

Next Steps​

Prevent future 4853 chargebacks:

  1. Use tracking on all shipments with delivery confirmation
  2. Make sure product descriptions match what you ship
  3. Process refunds promptly
  4. Make cancellation easy → Subscription compliance

See Also​

Something wrong on this page? Email matt at paymentsandrisk.com and say what needs fixing.