Skip to main content

Visa 13.2 - Cancelled Recurring Transaction

TL;DR
  • Permission for the recurring charge was withdrawn, or an account-status notice had already reached you, and billing continued. The dispute covers the unused portion, except on a Europe installment charge, where that limit doesn't apply
  • The customer's bank must file within 120 calendar days from the date the payment was processed, and every recurring charge can be disputed separately
  • The answers are specific: a later effective cancellation date with service supplied until then, a charge for services already received, proof the bank is wrong that you or your acquirer were told the account was closed, or use after permission to bill was withdrawn and before the dispute was processed. Dated logs carry them
  • Prevention: cancel on the spot, confirm by email, stop billing the same day

Got this code?​

Your deadline: The date on your notice wins. Your processor can set it earlier than Visa's standard limit for the response from your acquirer, the bank behind your processor (30 calendar days), and some domestic markets are shorter.

The claim: Billing continued after permission was withdrawn, or after an account-status notification. In Europe, some installment charges are covered too; the cases are in Visa's Table 11-97 (24 October 2026, section 11.11.3.1, pages 762-763). The bank disputes each recurring Visa transaction separately. A trial taken without informed agreement to future billing may belong under 13.5 instead.

Records that answer it:

  1. Cancellation records: did a cancellation request reach you?
  2. Billing dates: was this charge before or after the cancellation?
  3. Usage logs: did the customer keep using the service?

Next: Decide whether it's worth fighting, then fill in the response outline for this claim and follow the Representment Workflow.

When This Code Applies​

  • Subscription cancelled but charges continue
  • Free trial ended and charges began (if future billing was never agreed with full information, that may be 13.5)
  • Recurring billing after account closure
  • A renewal where permission to bill had been withdrawn, or an account-status ground applies. A missing renewal notice on its own isn't either ground
  • Charge after explicit cancellation request

What the claim needs​

  1. Withdrawal or account notice - Permission withdrawn, or an account-status notification, with the bank certifying the applicable date and contact
  2. No general grace period - Visa gives no general grace period for processing a cancellation
  3. Unused portion - The dispute is limited to the part of the service or merchandise not used. That limit doesn't apply to installment charges in Europe
  4. A covered charge - A recurring payment, or in Europe an installment charge in the cases Visa names. The account-status notice ground is its own case

Time Frames​

ScenarioDispute Window
Bank files120 calendar days from the date the payment was processed

NETWORK The issuer has 120 calendar days from the Transaction Processing Date to file 13.2 (Visa rules, 24 October 2026, Table 11-100, printed page 764); source links accessed 28 October 2026.

Recurring Transaction Requirements​

Valid Recurring Setup​

Visa's rules require you to:

  1. Get informed agreement - A clear agreement to the recurring charges, and keep it
  2. Disclose terms - Amount, frequency, duration
  3. Confirm the agreement as your region and product require - In Europe that confirmation is due within two business days
  4. Easy cancellation - Clear process to stop billing

Acknowledging a cancellation once it lands is good practice. Visa doesn't require that acknowledgment itself, unless another rule or your contract does.

Credential-on-File Indicators​

Your processor should code each later charge like this. Ask it to confirm:

  • Transaction initiated as recurring
  • Marked as a charge you started, not the customer (a merchant-initiated transaction, or MIT)
  • Linked back to the customer's first payment, or to the card check at signup if nothing was due then (the customer-initiated transaction, or CIT)

Representment Options​

The published routes are narrow:

  • A different effective cancellation date the customer asked for, with service supplied until then
  • A charge in arrears for services actually received
  • Proof the bank is wrong that you or your acquirer were told the account was closed
  • Use after the customer withdrew permission to bill and before the dispute was processed, up to the last permitted use date

In Europe, the first three routes don't apply where the bank had advised the account was closed, facilities were withdrawn, or the customer had died.

Records like a missing request in one channel, an unfinished cancellation flow, accepted terms or an active account help. On their own they don't answer the dispute.

1. A Later Effective Date, With Service Supplied​

When to use:

  • The customer asked for a later effective cancellation date
  • You supplied the service up to that date
  • This charge falls inside that supplied period

Evidence required:

  • The cancellation request, with its effective date
  • Dated records the service was supplied until that date
  • The charge date, set against that effective date

2. In Arrears for Service Already Received​

When to use:

  • The charge pays for service the customer already received
  • It is in arrears, not a charge for a new period
  • The amount matches the service received

Evidence required:

  • Dated service records for the period billed
  • The charge date, and the period it pays for
  • The accepted terms for that period

3. The Bank Says You Were Told the Account Was Closed​

When to use:

  • The bank says you or your acquirer were told the account was closed
  • Records refute that notice, or show it doesn't say what the bank says it does. Answer for whoever the bank names: if it names your acquirer, your own lack of notice doesn't answer it

Evidence required:

  • What actually reached you or your acquirer, with its date, or the gap where the bank says a notice sits
  • Why what arrived wasn't a closure notice, where something did arrive
  • Your account and billing records, set against what the bank says you were told

4. Use After Permission Was Withdrawn​

When to use:

  • Access logs show use after the customer withdrew permission to bill, and before the dispute was processed
  • The cancellation date stands as the last date the customer was permitted to use the service
  • The charge covers use only up to the last permitted use date

Evidence required:

  • Login/access logs
  • Usage records dated after that withdrawal, with the last permitted use date named
  • Cancellation and dispute dates, to place the use in that window

5. Refund Already Issued​

When to use:

  • Credit already processed
  • A refund still pending isn't an issued credit. Follow your processor's process for the open case instead of presenting it as received

Evidence required:

  • Refund transaction details
  • Refund confirmation

Required Documentation​

Evidence TypeWhere that leaves you
No cancellation + usage logsOnly within the published routes above
Accepted terms + policySupporting records, not a route on their own
Transaction before cancel requestDated records for the effective-date route
Refund already processedThe overlooked-credit route, with the processed record

Representment Time Frames​

StageWindow
Acquirer's response (Visa standard limit)30 calendar days; work to the date on your notice, which your processor can set earlier
Pre-arbitration, a second round if the bank pushes backYour acquirer answers, normally 30 calendar days from the attempt's Processing Date. One shorter exception: Tanzania domestic gets 10 calendar days. Time Frames has the windows
Arbitration, where Visa decidesThe bank files within 10 calendar days from the answer's Processing Date. Your working deadline stays the date on your notice

Trial Conversions​

Best Practices​

  1. Clear trial terms - Duration, conversion date
  2. Conversion notice - Remind the customer before the first paid charge, with the amount, the date and how to cancel. Visa's current rules require that notice at least seven days before the recurring charge. For a trial shorter than seven days, Verifi's guidance for the policy effective 18 April 2020 puts the conversion details in the signup confirmation. Ask your acquirer to confirm that treatment before you rely on it. Mastercard, on digital goods and services trials over 7 days: 3 to 7 days before the trial ends.
  3. Opt-out option - Easy to cancel before charge
  4. Confirmation at conversion - Receipt email
  5. Explicit consent - For conversion to paid

Sources (links accessed 28 October 2026): NETWORK Visa rules, 24 October 2026, section 5.8.11.1, Table 5-20; VENDOR Verifi on short trials; NETWORK Mastercard Transaction Processing Rules, section 5.4.2. See recurring billing

Common Trial Issues​

IssuePrevention
No conversion noticeAutomated reminder before the first paid charge
Surprise chargeClear terms at signup
Hidden billingTransparent pricing
Difficult cancellationEasy self-service

Which defenses hold up​

ScenarioWhat the evidence needs to show
Later effective dateThe request's effective date, with dated records the service ran until then
In arrears for service receivedDated records of service already received, for the period billed
Closure notice disputedWhat actually reached you or your acquirer, set against what the bank says
Qualifying useDated use after permission to bill was withdrawn and before the dispute was processed, with the cancellation date as the last permitted use date. An active account alone doesn't show it
No documentationNo records to support the defense

Track your own win rate by reason code.

Common Mistakes​

  1. No cancellation logs - Can't prove no request received
  2. Difficult cancellation - Drives chargebacks
  3. No pre-billing notice - Surprises customers
  4. Poor terms display - Can't prove consent
  5. Ignoring cancellations - Billing after a withdrawal is the dispute itself

Visa's Stop Payment Service​

Visa allows customers to request stops through their issuer:

  • Whether a stop reaches you, and how, follows your participating issuer's and acquirer's instructions. Don't assume a direct notice or a grace period
  • Honor it straight away. Charge again after that notice and you've handed them this dispute
  • 13.1 - Not Received
  • 13.6 - Credit Not Processed
  • 13.7 - Cancelled Merchandise

Prevention Strategies​

  1. Explicit opt-in - No pre-checked boxes
  2. Terms clearly displayed - Before purchase
  3. Amount and frequency - Clearly stated
  4. Cancellation process - Explained upfront
  5. Confirmation email - With all terms

Pre-Billing Notifications​

  1. Reminder emails - Before each charge
  2. Include amount - What will be charged
  3. Include date - When charge will occur
  4. Easy cancellation link - One-click unsubscribe
  5. Contact information - How to reach support

Easy Cancellation​

  1. Same channel as signup - Online signup = online cancel
  2. Self-service option - Account portal cancellation
  3. Quick processing - Honor immediately
  4. Confirmation - Send cancellation receipt
  5. No dark patterns - Don't make it difficult

Documentation​

  1. Log all communications - Emails, calls, chats
  2. Record consent - Timestamp and method
  3. Track cancellation requests - With confirmation
  4. Maintain usage logs - Prove service access

Next Steps​

Prevent future 13.2 chargebacks:

  1. Make cancellation as easy as signup
  2. Send a pre-billing reminder before each charge
  3. Honor a stop payment instruction immediately
  4. Review subscription compliance

See Also​

Something wrong on this page? Email matt at paymentsandrisk.com and say what needs fixing.